FICO has finally opened up a little about the number of points at stake when you are careless with your credit. The folks at FICO recently coughed up some new information about just how much a score can drop when you make a credit mistake.
Here's what they revealed:
If you've got great credit (say, a score of 780) you're going to pay more for your credit mistakes than someone with a 680. For instance, bankruptcy will shrink a 780 credit score to a paltry 540 (a loss of 240 points). If someone with a 680 credit score declares bankruptcy, though, they'll only get docked 150 points, dropping them to a 530. So the higher your score, the more points your credit mishaps will cost you.
You might be wondering why you should care if your credit score falls. Does it really cost you any money?
Yes, actually, if you go out and apply for a new loan. For instance, if you apply for a 30-year-fixed mortgage of $150,000 with a credit score of 735, you'll likely qualify for an average 4.688% interest rate. While that's a great interest rate, a score of 780 would have qualified you for one even lower, around 4.466%. Translated into dollars, the lower credit score means you're shelling out an extra $7,155 a year to your mortgage lender—not exactly chump change. (To plug in your own scenario, check out the myFICO.com loan calculator.)
You shouldn't take the numbers from this new FICO revelation as definitive though. They are strictly based on the specific situations of two hypothetical consumers. The first consumer has 10 credit cards, stays well under her credit limits, and has no other delinquencies on her report (hence the 780 credit score). The second consumer has less credit history, uses about half of his credit limits, and has a few negative marks (netting him the 680). The people at FICO then revealed what would happen to these two people's credit scores if they were to miss a payment, max out a card, negotiate a debt settlement, foreclose on a property, or declare bankruptcy.
The point? FICO will treat each one of us differently depending on our specific credit situation. While it may seem like FICO has finally leaked some real data about its formula, that's not the case. It remains as mysterious as ever. Sadly, the only way you'll truly find out how bad a credit mistake will hurt you is to make one.
The advice for maintaining a good score remains the same as it always has: pay your bills on time, only use about 10% of your credit limits, develop a long credit history (don't close accounts), and don't apply for new credit if you don't have to. For more about these credit tips, see the SpendOnLife guide to Improving Your Credit Score.
Comments
I'm surprised at the
Submitted on December 2nd, 2009 by Wojciech Kulicki (not verified)I'm surprised at the relatively small difference between a late payment & more drastic measures like debt settlement and foreclosure. I guess I just thought it would be more significant.
Or perhaps it's the late payment penalty that is too harsh...
It does seem like just one
Submitted on December 2nd, 2009 by Ryan Smith (not verified)It does seem like just one late payment shouldn't count against you so harshly.
One side of the argument is that a pattern of late payments should be penalized heavily not just a single late payment. The other argument is that first late payment could often be a precursor to more serious financial difficulty.
Note that the steep drop is
Submitted on December 2nd, 2009 by Carrie DavisNote that the steep drop is for a payment that is fully 30 days late. I don't think the drop would be as significant if, say, you sent in your check a few days after it was due. Your creditors might not like it, but they probably wouldn't report it as a full 30-day delinquency to the bureaus.
I had one late payment with a
Submitted on December 20th, 2009 by Bdigital (not verified)I had one late payment with a score of 760 and it dropped me to 660. The late payment was only $30!!!!
To Bdigital, Were you able to
Submitted on December 31st, 2009 by Visitor (not verified)To Bdigital,
Were you able to recover to a higher score after that? How long? I also have a 760 as of now but I missed a payment this month because it just slipped out of my mind. I've paid right away and still waiting for the next credit report. Thanks.